Reviews for In Stony Places
MicheleChadwick chapter 13 . 5/2
Really great emotional grab in this chapter! I love the understanding between Dean and Sam, the raw feels.
Please be advised I have no formal training in the art of writing, (though I have been fortunate enough to be haphazardly mentored due to friendship with ficwriters that do have) my background is in science, so please take all advice I offer with a pinch - or a whole fistful- of salt.
I wonder if you’ll link in Ezekiel‘s valley of the dry bones. Or Abraham, I always enjoyed that Dean was the righteous man since Abraham wasn’t exactly pure as the driven snow and yet the bible sat he believed God and it was credited to him as righteousness.
As always looking forward to forging on with this fic when you update next. No hurry though, good things take time
MicheleChadwick chapter 19 . 5/2
I’m glad you combined this, reading your previous chapters together would have felt more complete as well, a chapter ought to have a certain rhythm to it or a reader feels jipped. Thank you for soldiering through, I think that sin can sometimes be about what we think is sin, like in the bible when they talk about eating certain foods. For Dean sex isn’t a betrayal of his one true love because his truest love has nothing to do with sex (and I mean that in a totally non wincesty way.) Where as John felt he was betraying Mary by loving Kate and fathering Adam.
Keep up the fantastic work
Guest chapter 19 . 5/2
Can’t wait for your update.
daisy.schmitt.7 chapter 18 . 5/1
I don't know, but could the "Easter egg" be T. S. Eliot's poem? :D In general, your story is amazing! I truly love the concept of using the Arthur Legend in combination with the brothers. And it fits!
Jen chapter 14 . 4/27
So, get this... Ha, I love Sam! Loving this still. Can't wait to see where it is going.
MicheleChadwick chapter 14 . 4/26
If they are from the line of the grail keepers why would the zombies attack them to begin with?
Is there an intelligence (a tethered ghost) behind it that could tell they intended to destroy it even before Sam tossed salt and lighter fluid on it? And is the grail destroyed or just buried in rubble. I love the Winchester connection, is Dean our Galahad?
MicheleChadwick chapter 12 . 4/24
I love things in Supernatural fics that are based on real world websites and research, it gives a richness and grounding to the story.
Keep up the good work :-)
daisy.schmitt.7 chapter 11 . 4/19
I just want to say your story is amazing! Thanks for sharing your time and creativity with us. Stay safe. Greetz from Germany.
MicheleChadwick chapter 7 . 4/14
I love how creepy the poem is. The repetition only intensifies how sinister it is.
MicheleChadwick chapter 5 . 4/11
This is looking great so far! I can really see all the work you’ve put in to clarifying and sifting out the chaff.
It’s makes it much more coherent, grounded and professional than the original. A pleasure you read I’m really looking forward to where you take things from here.
-MC2