again with being scared shitless, the first chapter was terrifying in it’s own sense, like you didn’t know what would happen and you really wanna read on, but at the same time you don’t wanna know what happens. Hey, isn’t that what proper suspense is? The name and first chapter reminded me of Girl From Nowhere on Netflix.

This gave me the god dammed chills. Holy frikkin shirt balls, I’m chilled. OMG OMG OMG! This was so good, and realistic, and I love the writing style, and I don’t even know how to describe a writing style but still. From the first few chapters, I had thought that Jim was Harry. But I couldn’t for the life of me figure out how their names connected like Riddle’s did. And I gave up on that theory, so then I couldn’t really figure out the harryhermione paring, as it would have said past. The point is that this was an amazing story, and though I suspected Ron, the twists were absolutely THRILLING! And then when you realize that you don’t actually know something like you though you did. I WAS IN TERRIFIED TEARS FOR HALF OF THIS!

Chapter three has me in terrified tears, I’m scared to read more. Oh heavens. What’s the tag, Crime and mystery? I’m super scared. Oh lord. And it’s night time at almost 2 am. Oh lord.

"the old werewolf"
What exactly is your definition of "old"? Given that Lupin went to school with James Potter and Sirius, He can't be older than forty. Most people do not consider that "old". Especially since witches and wizards seem to live longer than non-magical people. Even non-magicals tend to live into their eighties or nineties, barring accidents or disease. So Remus Lupin is not old by the standards of anyone except a child.

I am very glad that I was able to find your stories. I have loved them all.

wow good story... just a question, why didn't the Weasleys question Rons death after Malfoy didn't confess due to Veritaserum? Next in line of suspiction would be Hermione, wouldn't she?

JM

Chem prof has a very short list of Favorites. I had read all of the others on that list and liked them, so I figured I’d give this one a try. I’m glad I did. I hated that Neville and Luna died, but it is a major character death story and it is a good one.
Bob, if you are still seeing these reviews, thank you for leaving this story up to be discovered all these years later.
O’D

OMG! 4 chapters in and I got it! Excellent! Abso bloody lutely brilliant!

Awww, this was beautiful! Thank you for sharing!

very nice story, but seriously, what is with the world of ffn and the word "jealousy" being *consistently* misspelled "jealously"?

This is my second time reading this. Just wanted to say that hagrid’s comment to Harry’s body brought tears to my eyes

xxx KUDOS xxx : )

Absolutely amazing and captivating story!

Great story!

I know this is an old story...it was really good but they all forgave him way to dang easily. And Ginny just hitting Harry, she should’ve pummeled her supposed best friend too.