Amazing story, really well written! Thank you for the break from reality ;)
A-Z

This story was absolutely amazing! Exactly what I was looking for when I wanted it!

*standing ovation*

This was one of the most excellently written stories I have ever read. Definitely deserves at least a place on my favorites list. ;)

... Elbereth's flame. This was a monumental task, and yet you achieved it and passed with full marks. I read this in one day - couldn't put it down. Thank you for letting me in on this adventure.

I'd read this story before, on a site where only members can leave reviews, and I'm delighted to find it here so that I can tell you how much I enjoyed it.

Truly excellent.

Hi,

I just wanted to leave a quick message saying how much I loved your story. It's so refreshing to see an author who doesn't portray legolas as superman or gimli as his dopey sidekick. I thought you o/c orcs were very good as well and the way the story linked back to the canon version was excellent. Keep on writing!

I really like it. Just the story I was looking to read.

An excellent story altogether. Some things better, some things worse. I'd have been interested in seeing this followed through with to the end.

What must Gondor be thinking, seeing a bunch of the Enemy's forces turning for Rohan? And Denethor has seen a Hobbit in his Palantir that he likely imagined was Sauron-Only.

He'd be really worried about that prophecy now. Especially since Aragorn has delared himself(Though not willingly), and you know Sauron would hold that on Denethor. I wonder what it'd all lead to?

i really liked the story until you brought Eowyn into the image. Legolas seemed to have changed almost immediately when one looks at his actions; with Gandalf and Gimli, he seemed reserved in nature, but once he met Eowyn he became almost boyish...

I don't know about you but it seemed to me that you tried to make a romance story out of this... and it was such a great story in the beginning. I can't help but say that the introduction of Eowyn into the picture disappointed me terribly.

This story is wonderful. I enjoyed reading every minute of it, and absolutely will return to read it numerous times. Thank you for writing this in a way that is Tolkien-esque, and is also completely believable. Excellent.

Oh! There's seriously only one more chapter left! I am gonna cry and scream and read this over and over it was so good! Congrats on making me cry again.

Great character development w/ Legolas btw, the best story I have ever read on fanfiction. OMG I will just die when this story is over. PST... Will there be a sequel by any chance?

It's sad that such a wonderful tale has come to an end. I enjoyed this a lot, thank you so much for writing it! And I just love your hobbits! How uncivilized of the Big Folk not to smoke pipeweed!

Thank you!

This was such an exciting and enjoyable, if somewhat harrowing in parts, story to read and I thought the way you managed to set-up each character to follow their original story-line at the end very well done.

Sorry that I missed reviewing a few of the previous chapters - but there was a problem with my emails and I did not see the story alerts until today.

*pouts* its over...

Nice ending, leaving Aragorn brooding a little more, meaning there MIGHT be a sequel? )

Love Legolas line "I am more than my weapon" when hes talking to Éowyn, by the way!

This was a fantastic story! I really loved how you managed to weave Saruman into the mix and then straighten everything out so the story would go on as originally written. Congratulations on writing a great story!