AWESOME-as usual! I love Supernatural too. But until your story it never occurred to me how Don is a lot like Dean and Charlie like Sam. Excellent plot and so much fun!

That was just too funny! I was snorting to myself and almost woke up my sweet doggy.

This was hysterical! I've kind of lost interest in Numb3rs (*cringes* I know, I know...I suck!), but that's only because I have become totally and completely obsessed with Supernatural. So when I saw this, and saw your name on it, I knew it'd be good. You never disappoint me. Loved the tongue-in-cheek references to fanfiction (LOL!), and the "You'd do either one" line just cracked me up. Plus, the thought of all the big, bad FBI agents running around with Dean-envy ('cause really, how can ya not?) made me happier than I've been in a long time. :) Thanks for the smile!

On a related note...when are you going to start writing SPN fiction? Think about it. ;)

Cute, funny, and well done!

lol very cute. Made me smile a bunch. I even laughed out loud and my dad looked at me a bit weird. :D Great Job!

That's hillarious! Love it!;)

That was fun.

Two totally different takes on why someone would watch Supernatural. The girls, so girly (gah!) and the boys into the weapons and discussing whether or not someone was 'doable'.

The line about fanfiction was hilarious. Someone would write about someone else without them knowing it? Surely not. :)

I have missed most of SPN Season 4 so there were a few spoilers for me but no biggie, gives me more to look forward to when the DVDs are released and I can watch it at my own pace. Season 5 sounds great!

Ms. GrahamCracker - I've only watched 2 episodes of Supernatural. I don't even know which one is Sam and which is Dean! Isn't that pitiful!

But, that said, I really enjoyed this story. I loved the contrast between the girls' and guys' conversations. You did a nice job of capturing the characters.

Jo

cool story, kind of hoped for sam and dean to show up, but just everyone talking about them was awesome!

I caught this before I left for work and had just enough time to print it out and take it with me. It truly brightened my lunch and I even laughed out loud a few times, prompting my co-workers to shake their heads and give me strange looks.

You have such a great imagination and I'm so glad that you choose to share it with us. (Although I had to use my own imagination in pictureing how Charlie looked in his costume, yum!)

I loved the story and thanks again for an early "Halloween Treat".

1st E.

I laughed and laughed. Brilliant.

So many jokes, so little time. I've never seen Supernatural, but I was still laughing. Nice work.

I really enjoyed this story it was so funny. Loved how the girls talked about Sam and Dean. Not watched the show but maybe I should.

Don admitting he watched and then the other admitting it too was so good.

Thanks for writing this.

Wendy

Great story.

I couldn't stop laughing at this sentence:

“I'm glad that doesn't really happen.” Charlie said. “Someone writing stories about you without you knowing about it is just...creepy.”

That was so funny and the rest of it was wonderful, too of course. I have to admit that I have never seen an episode of supernatural but I still so love this story that maybe I should watch some on day…

Have a Happy Halloween.

Lilly

That was awesome! I think that sums up the different motivations for watching SPN very nicely. And Don's admitting that he watches was hilarious. Nicely done!