Reviews for The Sorting Hat's Stand
Books85 chapter 36 . 7/14
About finding good reçomendation for HP fics: I keep a list of stories that I want to read, but it isn't always handy when I want to start something different , then I go to a writer I enjoy and look at what they have liked. It keeps me from reading the same type of story all the time. If you thought new, good HP fanficcs were thin on the ground in 2010, it's more so in 2020. I do keep finding new fandoms that way, also.
Bookss85 chapter 29 . 7/14
In canon, the escapee from Askaban was an animagus. Bellatrix hs escaped from Askaban. Ergo Bellatrix is an animagus . Is Neko poor crazy Bella?

I feel silly reviewing a fic that was last written on nearly 10 years sgo. But it is excellent, a very good read. Thanks!
Books85 chapter 19 . 7/14
How in the world sid Mundungus Fletcher manage to hatvh a Basilisk?
He is the only canon character I can think of with that aroma .

Enjoying this very much. Any vhance that you will complete the tale? Please?
Guest chapter 1 . 7/10
Thank you I've seen whole pages taken up with that dann song the first ok but story after story it's to much
sthrobbins chapter 43 . 5/25
Just as I feared- a waste of the reader's time, all for the author's self- indulgence.
sthrobbins chapter 37 . 5/25
7 tasks. 3 were 3 too many. I hate to imagine what excesses the reader will have to wade through to make even 2 tasks interesting enough to continue.
Lucifer-Satani chapter 36 . 5/16
a magic number of familiars - 21
Guest chapter 12 . 5/10
In response to your AN about badgers, I realize it was a few years ago...
Badgers are scary. Look up Honey Badger. And not just the pic...
Badgers are very protective of the family/Sett. They eat snakes. The venom is tasty. Do not under any circumstances, disturb a Sett. You may not survive.
Millie072 chapter 29 . 4/26
So Neko is Bellarix? The purple eyes was kind of a tip off.
Millie072 chapter 6 . 4/26
The device of having Flitwick using books to be able to see over his desk is cute, but has always seemed rather stupid. Both the headmaster & deputy are transfiguration masters, Flitwick is a charms master. Surely somewhere along the line a platform could have been created. The castle itself could have made some form of compensation to assist one of its' professors. Fun chapter, especially the Weasley twins' come- uppence.
Nerd chapter 12 . 4/16
When you said the phoenix was female, is she Fawkes? It wold make the most sense and I also checked against my copy of Chamber of Secrets with illustrations. Despite the many times Fawkes is said to be male, this is not true. In the book there is a guide on phoenixes and part of that is how to tell if they are male or female. I checked and double-checked a few pictures and yup, Fawkes is definitely, 100%, always has and will be, female.
yeah chapter 3 . 4/1
not that ı dont like snape getting a little bit desereved punishment but this is aa bit fast isnt it point of these fics is not to see what we want immediatly but to watch it happen in a set amount of time
yeah chapter 1 . 4/1
big daddy hat is about to lay some hits tonight
The Geeky Folkteller chapter 1 . 3/11
(Just go read the song from the book)

That most awesome, doesn't-give-a-shit line I have ever read in a fanfiction
Guest chapter 37 . 2/24
Hermione’s insistence on demanding to know about what she has zero business/reason to know, having her head shoved so far up every adult’s behind that when they open their mouths you can see her eyes, and her constantly correcting *other people’s* language is SO DAMN ANNOYING!
3,877 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »