I always imagined Remus and Poppy had a special bond. I just want to hug them both.

My heart.

I love Poppy way too much...and Rem...

WHY

Sad

Really beautiful, sad but beautiful! Loved it!

That... got to me... she probably thought of him as family... Great job. This was a beautifully sad piece of writing.

oh, the ending! I very nearly teared up. It was well written and interesting!

Kali

This is absolutely beautiful. And that's all I can say. Beautiful.

Wow, great story -

It's just like when Lily left Prof. Slughorn the fish. Great idea.

Awwww, that was so sad but also really sweet. remus is so thoughtful

That made me... Really sad, actually. XP

But I enjoyed the story, really.

Awww... This made me so sad and happy at the same time.

I love Poppy! XD

Hi!

This is such a cute fanfiction. I don't see many featuring Poppy, and I think, based on your fiction, we could use a lot more. Your characterization of her is fantastic. Instead of the strict Poppy we know, we also get a softer, emotional side. And seeing her lasting effect on Lupin was a great idea.

The only thing I noticed is that sometimes you have mistakes in punctuation. You'll use commas instead of semicolons in places. There are also a couple of spelling errors that could easily be caught with a quick re-reading.

On that note, I'd like to refer you to a creative writing Harry Potter based roleplaying site called Sonora Academy (www. sonoramagic .com). We have a great author based and would love to have you on board! We're accepting applications for our new term now, so you should definitely check it out. Feel free to message me with any questions :)

Keep writing!

-HinataInuzuka

Um, wow. That was amazing. Beautiful. Stunning.

I mean, not many people would think to write such an original story (and execute it so beautifully). We don't really know much about Poppy from the books, but I guess I (and probably not many other people) never really stopped to think about what kind of relationship Remus would have with her.

I loved the idea that the flowers would die when Remus did, that was so touching. Generally, Poppy's thoughts on Remus and Remus' implied opinion of her were lovely.

So thank you so much for writing such a beautiful, emotional and altogether very touching story. I'm not really thinking straight enough to give you a very comprehensive and coherent review right now, but I really wanted you to know how beautiful I thought this story was. Please keep writing!

Merry Christmas, too. : )

Beautiful, simply beautiful.