Oh so lovely. Thank you.

This is one TERRIFIC story, and I will be shocked if you weren't brought up Catholic like me. You got so many of the nuances exactly right. I loved it!

Such a unique, powerful story. Congrats :) I truly loved it

OMG! That was so great! I feel a little naughty for enjoying it so much! Great job.

What a great story! It seems such a realistic portrayal of the struggle and inner conflict that people in Carlisle might experience. The relationship between Carlisle and Edward was so tender, yet passionate...well done!

Loved this!

I had some doubts over how interested I'd be in a story of a religious nature but I was so wrong. This one won me over so completely! I really loved the courtship and Carlisle's thoughts that went with his change of heart. And the boy-lovin' of course! Really really well done.

That was surprisingly amazing.
You captured catholic guilt really well.
5 stars

sinfully good. :)

This is a truly excellent oneshot, which felt as real as it did exquisitely, torturously hot.

Thank you for sharing your talent.

Oh that was lovely.
"I'm queer Patrick" - that was priceless.

Holy (no pun intended) schitt. That. Was. Amazing. It's not too often that stories of this quality and magnitude are seen in Fanficland but we have this incredible story that delves into almost every human emotion: lust, love, guilt, happiness, regret. It's all there and presented in a way that draws the reader in and refuses to let go until the very end. Superb job. This will forever be in my favorites.

Excellent story! Thanks for sharing it! :)

Thanks for sharing. I did have my reservations with the whole priest scandals issue in the Catholic Church. But lord help me I loved it. The ending was so perfect it almost hurt to read. Is it sad that the most recent reviewers are fellow Facebook slash-h00rs? lol Great job, darling.

Wow, this was EXCELLANT! Too bad the taste of the forbidden contest was hetero only...lol. Dayum that was hot!