Reviews for The First Gothic - Book One - A Wizard In Training
alec-potter chapter 3 . 12/10/2019
Is it possible by temporal displacement for Damien to 'console' Narcissa
Guest chapter 34 . 8/23/2019
Ooo, that's a good one. "Bah, homework," rather than ''bah, humbug!" Not very Christmassy, but probably just as well for the second task, itself, eh?
Guest chapter 33 . 8/23/2019
A Ladybug, and NOT a bluish Water Beetle with markings reminiscent of gaudy eyeglasses on its 'face?' Nope, no idea why that might be significant.
ZhaWarudo chapter 40 . 6/22/2019
It's not bad but not great either. I dropped it on the 6th chapter and here are some of the flaws besides the lack of excitement or intrigue.
You ranted how useless transfigurations of beetles to buttons or matches to needles were.
Those are just practice spells, they don't have to be useful...
As far as I can tell everytime you were supposed to write "you're" you wrote "your", and I don't think you ever even actually neeeded to use "your".
First training with stunners, Neville and Ginny freaked out, Luna called it brutal...it was just a stuner.
Room of Requirement conjures anything needed, it's not just a room of lost things you can actually take out.
I don't why you are stuck on calling his followers Death Eaters, it has a horrible public image, it's not original and as far as I know he doesn't plan to lead terrorits but revolutionares with some morals.
BigDMan chapter 20 . 5/30/2019
Ha! When I read that line about combining Pokemon and beautiful women all I thought of was Sekirei! I hope you will do/have done a version of Gothic Sekirei
Andorxor chapter 17 . 5/27/2019
If you give Neville a sword he could use some training, maybe Elenia would be a good place for a summer vacation.
Kitrane chapter 33 . 3/26/2019
Hold on. This is plot contrivance like another of your stories. He just conveniently forgets rita skeeter? At least I assume it's her. Though I thought she was a water beetle. Or is that why he doesnt realize it since she has a different form in this universe?
Shadowpawzzz chapter 40 . 2/15/2019
awww poo such a shame but I can understand at forty chapters its easy to get tired of a story.
Guest chapter 1 . 7/23/2018
How come no marvel or star wars
Arsenal chapter 40 . 7/1/2018
Sigh. I only finished the story for the sake of finishing it. It started so well that I had high hopes for it. But then it just devolved from there. Your SI was mired with weakness, self-doubt and vacillation. As great a premise it was, the execution left much to be desired.
Arsenal chapter 33 . 7/1/2018
You had so many good ideas I would have wanted to see fleshed out: inventing, creating businesses, taking over the wizarding world. But then you make chapters such as a date with Hermione and now this marriage with her and I despair. This is not worth writing about.
Arsenal chapter 27 . 7/1/2018
I had been highly entertained thus far and then you go and do this silly fluff, and with Granger of all people. A colossal mistake.
Ronin Kenshin chapter 40 . 6/14/2018
the first is very different from other gothics great work
Thedudeist chapter 37 . 5/30/2018
for what you said in the last chapter, its mainly empathy. You simply don't do to others what you don't want to be done to yourself, because you know how they'd feel. Also, i dont really get this last scene.. I'd think Damien would assume it was a scheme.
Thedudeist chapter 36 . 5/29/2018
any group of people who relied on teenage boys to save them werent worth saving.
soo...basically every anime ever? bwaahahahah. Well alright not every one, but the majority, even the seinens.
337 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »