I like it. Well done.

Really good story! I very much liked it!
To bad the boy's couldn't help with the hunt.

This is great. You've done a really seamless job of combining these worlds. I really enjoy the characterization and how the relationships were established; incredibly real. A Love this!

I much enjoyed this. This has good, solid writing with strong characterizations. You had me guessing to the end what Death would say to Dean. Thank you for posting.

Awesome. Good characterization, and SPN!Death's explanation made sense.

Msmk is a retared bitch and her stories are crap and this ok but spn is better and dean is the best! Your writing was not that great either tho and icahbod is boring

That was fabulous! I loved the "'Course not, he likes pizza."
Overall, I loved the characterization of Dean and Sam, and Ichabod's reaction to the beer bottles and the second death and... ad;ghasdl;fj you just hit the nail on the head :)
The only one thing I could suggest for further sleepy hollow fic is the Lieutenant thing at the end.
I'm cosplaying as Ichabod over the summer, so I did my research-the whole reason he addresses her as "Leftenant" is because during the US Revolution, the French "Lieutenant" had not yet worked its way into the English language. So it's a nice little addition to the whole time-traveling sense of Ichabod.
I LOVED THIS FIC THOUGH, AND I LOVE YOUR WRITING 3

Nice and even tho I dont like the show sleepy hollow at all and abbie seemed like a bitch. And dean is awesome!

Very interesting job on this.

Nice crossover and dean and Sam were the best and I'm not a fan of sleepy hollow but I love spn it's the best show. And love dean/Abbie and she would be lucky to be with dean. I don't like icahbod tho he seems boring and it i hated death . Dean is never annyoing . Abbie seemed like a bitch at first but love how dean interacted with her. I bet she really liked dean too. Anyway I didn't really like the time line cause I thought it would be season9 of spn. And the winchesters are the best heros. And dean is the best!

This was so amazing. I never read crossovers but this was just...I mean the worlds mixed so well. I just wish it was longer or something I don't know. This was a great story. Nothing was resolved but it wasn't supposed to be because the Winchesters were out of their territory.
The writing was solid and the story flowed very well. I would really like to see them meet again on one of those sleepy hollow middle demons that don't really have much to do with the apocolypse but kind of do.
Anyway this was a good read and I hope you write more.

This is such a good crossover; you've captured both worlds perfectly and this reconciliation of the two versions of Death makes sense. I like how Death told Dean this isn't your apocalypse to stop. Ironically, I liked Abbie's reaction to the SPN version of Death.

At any rate, I can see the possibilities of more crossover with SPN if you choose to write them. Perhaps with Sheriff Jodie Mills, another woman brought reluctantly into the fight like Abbie.

Take care & thank you again for the story.

There might not be that many Sleepy Hollow crossovers yet, but this is the best I've seen so far.