Reviews for Shadows Under the Oak Tree |
---|
ShadowCero chapter 36 . 12/14/2019 Coming in over a decade after the original ending to say that I still love this fic. This is easily the most enjoyable and well written fic I've read. The delve into Canas' character is believable, interesting, and is pretty close to how I would see him. Lily became such a likeable character and I found myself caring about this OC almost more than Canas! Honestly I can't really articulate how much I like this fic and how sentimental it to me. |
darkeldar chapter 37 . 11/26/2019 Well done. It is exceptionally rare that such a minor character gets a thought-out and loving portrayal. |
anon chapter 21 . 10/28/2016 being a writer is so amazing. you can flip the tides on a readers emotions. tbh, i've tried really hard to like kelial but it's been difficult and i guess his personality/characterization really clashed with mine but holy shit did this chapter become pivotal in my assessment of him. KELIAL POOR SWEET BABY I HOPE HE FINDS PEACE AND HAPPINESS AT LAST OKAY BECAUSE HE DESERVES IT TOO AND BLESS YOU FOR WRITING THIS NEW SIDE OF HIM |
Forgot Password chapter 38 . 7/11/2016 I didn't think I would read your story this fast. Last time, it took me a week. I guess that age has something to do with it, but I was up until 3 last night and I did need something to do- Anyway, I adore this story. I do think that it is one of the best I have ever read. If given a choice between Conrad's Heart of Darkness and this? I might choose this. And I loved Heart of Darkness. That's how insightful and enjoyable and wonderful your writing is. The humanity you put into these characters is nothing less then astounding. |
Forgot Password chapter 21 . 7/10/2016 He never thought of himself as lonely, but she was "enriching" (was that the word? It takes so long to load on mobile ). I heard a very similar thing from a good friend once. ...thank you. Once again, this chapter has been magnificent, and I have no complaints whatsoever. |
Forgot Password chapter 14 . 7/10/2016 The amount of work and amount of detail you put into this story is simply amazing. You must have spent quite a time researching and thinking and planning. Hell, even your puns are interesting! |
Forgot Password chapter 8 . 7/10/2016 My oh my, I forgot just how lifelike you make the characters. You write so well from Canas' perspective, but also superbly in Lily's. If this were a book, then I do think it would become a classic quite quickly. Er, I mean that in a good way of course. |
Forgot Password chapter 3 . 7/9/2016 Your writing is magnificent, as magnificent as I remember it being. Or even more so than that. And since I have the knowledge and age to understand it better, I find myself enjoying this piece very very much. Maybe even more than the first time I read it. So thank you. Also, I couldn't help but draw parallels between Canas and Lily and some people in my life. Or a couple of people, me being one of them. ...The fact that I can relate to someone so scatterbrained is telling though. |
Forgot password chapter 1 . 7/9/2016 ...the last time I read this story, I was thirteen and did not know how to spell violin. That was a long time ago. I hope you're still around though, friend. I'm going to reread this over the next few days- I remember this as being an exquisitely crafted work of art, and now that I'm older, I know I'll be able to appreciate it even more. And I'll probably make a new account and favorite and all of that. And give serious reviews. And now I am rambling. |
DearestDissapointment chapter 30 . 6/8/2016 Is Lizard meant to be a comment on how Legault's Japanese name means Lizard when romanized and then translated into spanish? |
EricLightscythe chapter 37 . 3/29/2016 Absolutely loved this story. It's nice to read a slow paced story once in a while. And you've pulled off the love angle very well, without the unneeded smoochy smoochums most authors tend to overdo. Although the ending was kind of sad :/ Thanks for the good read! |
Avatar of Wurms chapter 38 . 2/21/2016 Well. This isn't favorited. Oops. Should have done that like two years ago, it being my favorite Fire Emblem story and what not. |
Someone chapter 30 . 2/18/2016 Good story, do you write others like this one ? P.S ( don't answer if you can't ): (es)étais-tu un étudiant en littérature française ? |
Enigma infinite chapter 38 . 5/20/2014 Magnificent! |
Zantetsuken Reverse chapter 38 . 5/17/2014 I... I only started to read this recently, but... it's great. Hugh returns, Nino and Jaffar return with Canas... I don't think that love should be a whirlwind. It should be steady. |