Damn... I'm still sad because Gil is still human and they will still be separated aww... Well at least they reunited also this fic was started and finished the year I was born. This is so old! I'm glad I saw this while strolling through fics with Elrond as a tag from page 110 to 1. (Yes, I'm starting from the oldest to newest hence I saw this fic from 2002 the year I was born yey!) Congrats to you for the latest review from 2020!

this is so good.

Amazing story ! I loved every lines of it. Thank you for writing such a masterpiece !

Oh thank you for that happy ending!

I have read many fanfictions. Yours is by far one of the best I have ever read in all the years I've been reading them. A very warm well done to you. Your rendition of Elrond was beautiful, and may have inspired me to write again.

I read this years ago. I loved it then as I love it now. This is a masterful piece of writing. You have created a remarkable world for this story. It took time to find it once again. I had to resort to all manner of Google searches to light upon it. Thank you for this.

This story actually brought me to tears at the end. By far the best fan fiction I've read so far.

Glad I found this, it is lovely!

I was afraid to click on this story for a long time because anything war related tends to wring my heart out. You've done a good job with this setting. It's not too angst filled, but it does leave me deeply saddened.

I also like your OC. While she has heroic skills, what makes her attractive is loyalty. You've emphasized not fighting skills, but human skills and that's what identifies her non-Mary Sure.

My favourite part is your idea, I'm surprised there aren't more variations on this theme. I find your reasons for introducing the heroine into the story very much realistic. You've managed to mix legendary aspect into the story like it belongs there with the OC. I wish there was a bit more development in her outlook of the world and a bit more depth from Elrond (though it could be tricky because the story is from Gil's point of view). Otherwise, this is a very well written story.

This was pretty awesome. You are super talented and I hope that you are doing really really well. (I read the whole thing on the Magic Tortoise site you linked to earlier.) I ****LOVED**** the ending. It was awesome.

You rock.

It has been ages since you wrote this, but thank you- it is great!

Loved it. Incredibly written and very moving...

...

That story is the most 'complete' one I have ever read. I mean the characters, storyline etc. And opposite to most fanfics- gramaticly correct.

My God, with THAT story You reduced me to some sappy romantic! And, hell, I thank You.

I love this story. LOVE. And I do not use that word often.

Keep on writing.

Thank You once more.

I love your poem and the rhyming

That chapter was BRILLIANT. I loved the way you captured the battle and kept the style/diction so beautifully dark . Well done!